The reliability of replications: a study in computational reproductions.

Breznau N, Rinke EM, Wuttke A, Adem M, Adriaans J, Akdeniz E, Alvarez-Benjumea A, Andersen HK, Auer D, Azevedo F, Bahnsen O, Bai L, Balzer D, Bauer PC, Bauer G, Baumann M, Baute S, Benoit V, Bernauer J, Berning C, Berthold A, Bethke FS, Biegert T, Blinzler K, Blumenberg JN, Bobzien L, Bohman A, Bol T, Bostic A, Brzozowska Z, Burgdorf K, Burger K, Busch K, Castillo JC, Chan N, Christmann P, Connelly R, Czymara CS, Damian E, de Rooij EA, Ecker A, Edelmann A, Eder C, Eger MA, Ellerbrock S, Forke A, Forster A, Freire D, Gaasendam C, Gavras K, Gayle V, Gessler T, Gnambs T, Godefroidt A, Grömping M, Groß M, Gruber S, Gummer T, Hadjar A, Halbherr V, Heisig JP, Hellmeier S, Heyne S, Hirsch M, Hjerm M, Hochman O, Höffler JH, Hövermann A, Hunger S, Hunkler C, Huth-Stöckle N, Ignácz ZS, Israel S, Jacobs L, Jacobsen J, Jaeger B, Jungkunz S, Jungmann N, Kanjana J, Kauff M, Khan S, Khatua S, Kleinert M, Klinger J, Kolb JP, Kołczyńska M, Kuk J, Kunißen K, Kurti Sinatra D, Langenkamp A, Lee RC, Lersch PM, Liu D, Löbel LM, Lutscher P, Mader M, Madia JE, Malancu N, Maldonado L, Marahrens H, Martin N, Martinez P, Mayerl J, Mayorga OJ, McDonnell R, McManus P, McWagner K, Meeusen C, Meierrieks D, Mellon J, Merhout F, Merk S, Meyer D, Micheli L, Mijs J, Moya C, Neunhoeffer M, Nüst D, Nygård O, Ochsenfeld F, Otte G, Pechenkina A, Pickup M, Prosser C, Raes L, Ralston K, Ramos M, Reichert F, Roets A, Rogers J, Ropers G, Samuel R, Sand G, Sanhueza Petrarca C, Schachter A, Schaeffer M, Schieferdecker D, Schlueter E, Schmidt K, Schmidt R, Schmidt-Catran A, Schmiedeberg C, Schneider J, Schoonvelde M, Schulte-Cloos J, Schumann S, Schunck R, Seuring J, Silber H, Sleegers W, Sonntag N, Staudt A, Steiber N, Steiner ND, Sternberg S, Stiers D, Stojmenovska D, Storz N, Striessnig E, Stroppe AK, Suchow JW, Teltemann J, Tibajev A, Tung B, Vagni G, Van Assche J, van der Linden M, van der Noll J, Van Hootegem A, Vogtenhuber S, Voicu B, Wagemans F, Wehl N, Werner H, Wiernik BM, Winter F, Wolf C, Wu C, Yamada Y, Zakula B, Zhang N, Ziller C, Zins S, Żółtak T, Nguyen HHV

Open source

DOI: 10.1098/rsos.241038
Published: 2025 Mar
Container: Royal Society open science
Publisher: Not recorded
Open access: yes

Credibility signals

limited evidence Score 45/100 under policy 1.0.0. This is a metadata assessment, not a judgment of the paper's conclusions.

Show all credibility signals

cautionDOI registered: No matching Crossref record was present in this response. Source: Crossref; license: CC0 metadata
cautionDOI resolves: No matching Crossref record was present in this response. Source: Crossref; license: CC0 metadata
not scoredDirectory of Open Access Journals: No matching DOAJ record was present in this response. No allow-list match; this is not evidence of low credibility. Source: DOAJ; license: CC0
not scoredMEDLINE indexed: Not checked or no result supplied; no credibility inference made. Source: No authority result supplied; license: Unknown
not scoredOpenAlex core source: Not checked or no result supplied; no credibility inference made. Source: No authority result supplied; license: Unknown
not scoredKnown publisher allow-list: Not checked or no result supplied; no credibility inference made. Source: No authority result supplied; license: Unknown
not scoredROR affiliation: Not checked or no result supplied; no credibility inference made. Source: No authority result supplied; license: Unknown
not scoredRetraction Watch retraction: No retraction notice matched this DOI in the deployed snapshot. No matching event found; coverage may be incomplete. Source: Retraction Watch; license: CC BY 4.0
not scoredRetraction Watch expression of concern: No expression of concern notice matched this DOI in the deployed snapshot. No matching event found; coverage may be incomplete. Source: Retraction Watch; license: CC BY 4.0
not scoredRetraction Watch correction: No correction notice matched this DOI in the deployed snapshot. No matching event found; coverage may be incomplete. Source: Retraction Watch; license: CC BY 4.0
not scoredRetraction Watch reinstatement: No reinstatement notice matched this DOI in the deployed snapshot. No matching event found; coverage may be incomplete. Source: Retraction Watch; license: CC BY 4.0
supportingOpen access status: Normalized open-access status: open. Source: Normalized work metadata; license: Caller-provided; provenance license not supplied to scorer
not scoredPublication license: Not checked or no result supplied; no credibility inference made. Source: No authority result supplied; license: Unknown
not scoredPublication version: A publication version was supplied but is not scored. Source: Normalized work metadata; license: Caller-provided; provenance license not supplied to scorer
cautionMetadata completeness: 5 of 6 scored descriptive metadata groups are present; missing fields increase uncertainty. Source: Normalized work metadata; license: Caller-provided; provenance license not supplied to scorer

Cite this work

BibTeX

@article{allodium:10.1098/rsos.241038,
  title = {The reliability of replications: a study in computational reproductions.},
  author = {Breznau N and Rinke EM and Wuttke A and Adem M and Adriaans J and Akdeniz E and Alvarez-Benjumea A and Andersen HK and Auer D and Azevedo F and Bahnsen O and Bai L and Balzer D and Bauer PC and Bauer G and Baumann M and Baute S and Benoit V and Bernauer J and Berning C and Berthold A and Bethke FS and Biegert T and Blinzler K and Blumenberg JN and Bobzien L and Bohman A and Bol T and Bostic A and Brzozowska Z and Burgdorf K and Burger K and Busch K and Castillo JC and Chan N and Christmann P and Connelly R and Czymara CS and Damian E and de Rooij EA and Ecker A and Edelmann A and Eder C and Eger MA and Ellerbrock S and Forke A and Forster A and Freire D and Gaasendam C and Gavras K and Gayle V and Gessler T and Gnambs T and Godefroidt A and Grömping M and Groß M and Gruber S and Gummer T and Hadjar A and Halbherr V and Heisig JP and Hellmeier S and Heyne S and Hirsch M and Hjerm M and Hochman O and Höffler JH and Hövermann A and Hunger S and Hunkler C and Huth-Stöckle N and Ignácz ZS and Israel S and Jacobs L and Jacobsen J and Jaeger B and Jungkunz S and Jungmann N and Kanjana J and Kauff M and Khan S and Khatua S and Kleinert M and Klinger J and Kolb JP and Kołczyńska M and Kuk J and Kunißen K and Kurti Sinatra D and Langenkamp A and Lee RC and Lersch PM and Liu D and Löbel LM and Lutscher P and Mader M and Madia JE and Malancu N and Maldonado L and Marahrens H and Martin N and Martinez P and Mayerl J and Mayorga OJ and McDonnell R and McManus P and McWagner K and Meeusen C and Meierrieks D and Mellon J and Merhout F and Merk S and Meyer D and Micheli L and Mijs J and Moya C and Neunhoeffer M and Nüst D and Nygård O and Ochsenfeld F and Otte G and Pechenkina A and Pickup M and Prosser C and Raes L and Ralston K and Ramos M and Reichert F and Roets A and Rogers J and Ropers G and Samuel R and Sand G and Sanhueza Petrarca C and Schachter A and Schaeffer M and Schieferdecker D and Schlueter E and Schmidt K and Schmidt R and Schmidt-Catran A and Schmiedeberg C and Schneider J and Schoonvelde M and Schulte-Cloos J and Schumann S and Schunck R and Seuring J and Silber H and Sleegers W and Sonntag N and Staudt A and Steiber N and Steiner ND and Sternberg S and Stiers D and Stojmenovska D and Storz N and Striessnig E and Stroppe AK and Suchow JW and Teltemann J and Tibajev A and Tung B and Vagni G and Van Assche J and van der Linden M and van der Noll J and Van Hootegem A and Vogtenhuber S and Voicu B and Wagemans F and Wehl N and Werner H and Wiernik BM and Winter F and Wolf C and Wu C and Yamada Y and Zakula B and Zhang N and Ziller C and Zins S and Żółtak T and Nguyen HHV},
  year = {2025},
  journal = {Royal Society open science},
  doi = {10.1098/rsos.241038},
  url = {https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.241038}
}

RIS

TY  - JOUR
TI  - The reliability of replications: a study in computational reproductions.
AU  - Breznau N
AU  - Rinke EM
AU  - Wuttke A
AU  - Adem M
AU  - Adriaans J
AU  - Akdeniz E
AU  - Alvarez-Benjumea A
AU  - Andersen HK
AU  - Auer D
AU  - Azevedo F
AU  - Bahnsen O
AU  - Bai L
AU  - Balzer D
AU  - Bauer PC
AU  - Bauer G
AU  - Baumann M
AU  - Baute S
AU  - Benoit V
AU  - Bernauer J
AU  - Berning C
AU  - Berthold A
AU  - Bethke FS
AU  - Biegert T
AU  - Blinzler K
AU  - Blumenberg JN
AU  - Bobzien L
AU  - Bohman A
AU  - Bol T
AU  - Bostic A
AU  - Brzozowska Z
AU  - Burgdorf K
AU  - Burger K
AU  - Busch K
AU  - Castillo JC
AU  - Chan N
AU  - Christmann P
AU  - Connelly R
AU  - Czymara CS
AU  - Damian E
AU  - de Rooij EA
AU  - Ecker A
AU  - Edelmann A
AU  - Eder C
AU  - Eger MA
AU  - Ellerbrock S
AU  - Forke A
AU  - Forster A
AU  - Freire D
AU  - Gaasendam C
AU  - Gavras K
AU  - Gayle V
AU  - Gessler T
AU  - Gnambs T
AU  - Godefroidt A
AU  - Grömping M
AU  - Groß M
AU  - Gruber S
AU  - Gummer T
AU  - Hadjar A
AU  - Halbherr V
AU  - Heisig JP
AU  - Hellmeier S
AU  - Heyne S
AU  - Hirsch M
AU  - Hjerm M
AU  - Hochman O
AU  - Höffler JH
AU  - Hövermann A
AU  - Hunger S
AU  - Hunkler C
AU  - Huth-Stöckle N
AU  - Ignácz ZS
AU  - Israel S
AU  - Jacobs L
AU  - Jacobsen J
AU  - Jaeger B
AU  - Jungkunz S
AU  - Jungmann N
AU  - Kanjana J
AU  - Kauff M
AU  - Khan S
AU  - Khatua S
AU  - Kleinert M
AU  - Klinger J
AU  - Kolb JP
AU  - Kołczyńska M
AU  - Kuk J
AU  - Kunißen K
AU  - Kurti Sinatra D
AU  - Langenkamp A
AU  - Lee RC
AU  - Lersch PM
AU  - Liu D
AU  - Löbel LM
AU  - Lutscher P
AU  - Mader M
AU  - Madia JE
AU  - Malancu N
AU  - Maldonado L
AU  - Marahrens H
AU  - Martin N
AU  - Martinez P
AU  - Mayerl J
AU  - Mayorga OJ
AU  - McDonnell R
AU  - McManus P
AU  - McWagner K
AU  - Meeusen C
AU  - Meierrieks D
AU  - Mellon J
AU  - Merhout F
AU  - Merk S
AU  - Meyer D
AU  - Micheli L
AU  - Mijs J
AU  - Moya C
AU  - Neunhoeffer M
AU  - Nüst D
AU  - Nygård O
AU  - Ochsenfeld F
AU  - Otte G
AU  - Pechenkina A
AU  - Pickup M
AU  - Prosser C
AU  - Raes L
AU  - Ralston K
AU  - Ramos M
AU  - Reichert F
AU  - Roets A
AU  - Rogers J
AU  - Ropers G
AU  - Samuel R
AU  - Sand G
AU  - Sanhueza Petrarca C
AU  - Schachter A
AU  - Schaeffer M
AU  - Schieferdecker D
AU  - Schlueter E
AU  - Schmidt K
AU  - Schmidt R
AU  - Schmidt-Catran A
AU  - Schmiedeberg C
AU  - Schneider J
AU  - Schoonvelde M
AU  - Schulte-Cloos J
AU  - Schumann S
AU  - Schunck R
AU  - Seuring J
AU  - Silber H
AU  - Sleegers W
AU  - Sonntag N
AU  - Staudt A
AU  - Steiber N
AU  - Steiner ND
AU  - Sternberg S
AU  - Stiers D
AU  - Stojmenovska D
AU  - Storz N
AU  - Striessnig E
AU  - Stroppe AK
AU  - Suchow JW
AU  - Teltemann J
AU  - Tibajev A
AU  - Tung B
AU  - Vagni G
AU  - Van Assche J
AU  - van der Linden M
AU  - van der Noll J
AU  - Van Hootegem A
AU  - Vogtenhuber S
AU  - Voicu B
AU  - Wagemans F
AU  - Wehl N
AU  - Werner H
AU  - Wiernik BM
AU  - Winter F
AU  - Wolf C
AU  - Wu C
AU  - Yamada Y
AU  - Zakula B
AU  - Zhang N
AU  - Ziller C
AU  - Zins S
AU  - Żółtak T
AU  - Nguyen HHV
PY  - 2025
JO  - Royal Society open science
DO  - 10.1098/rsos.241038
UR  - https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.241038
ER  -

APA

N, B., EM, R., A, W., M, A., J, A., E, A., A, A., HK, A., D, A., F, A., O, B., L, B., D, B., PC, B., G, B., M, B., S, B., V, B., J, B., C, B., A, B., FS, B., T, B., K, B., JN, B., L, B., A, B., T, B., A, B., Z, B., K, B., K, B., K, B., JC, C., N, C., P, C., R, C., CS, C., E, D., EA, D. R., A, E., A, E., C, E., MA, E., S, E., A, F., A, F., D, F., C, G., K, G., V, G., T, G., T, G., A, G., M, G., M, G., S, G., T, G., A, H., V, H., JP, H., S, H., S, H., M, H., M, H., O, H., JH, H., A, H., S, H., C, H., N, H., ZS, I., S, I., L, J., J, J., B, J., S, J., N, J., J, K., M, K., S, K., S, K., M, K., J, K., JP, K., M, K., J, K., K, K., D, K. S., A, L., RC, L., PM, L., D, L., LM, L., P, L., M, M., JE, M., N, M., L, M., H, M., N, M., P, M., J, M., OJ, M., R, M., P, M., K, M., C, M., D, M., J, M., F, M., S, M., D, M., L, M., J, M., C, M., M, N., D, N., O, N., F, O., G, O., A, P., M, P., C, P., L, R., K, R., M, R., F, R., A, R., J, R., G, R., R, S., G, S., C, S. P., A, S., M, S., D, S., E, S., K, S., R, S., A, S., C, S., J, S., M, S., J, S., S, S., R, S., J, S., H, S., W, S., N, S., A, S., N, S., ND, S., S, S., D, S., D, S., N, S., E, S., AK, S., JW, S., J, T., A, T., B, T., G, V., J, V. A., M, V. D. L., J, V. D. N., A, V. H., S, V., B, V., F, W., N, W., H, W., BM, W., F, W., C, W., C, W., Y, Y., B, Z., N, Z., C, Z., S, Z., T, Ż., & HHV, N. (2025). The reliability of replications: a study in computational reproductions.. Royal Society open science. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.241038

Source records

pubmed · retrieved 2026-09-24T20:45:20.861Z