Same data, different analysts: variation in effect sizes due to analytical decisions in ecology and evolutionary biology.

Gould E, Fraser HS, Parker TH, Nakagawa S, Griffith SC, Vesk PA, Fidler F, Hamilton DG, Abbey-Lee RN, Abbott JK, Aguirre LA, Alcaraz C, Aloni I, Altschul D, Arekar K, Atkins JW, Atkinson J, Baker CM, Barrett M, Bell K, Bello SK, Beltrán I, Berauer BJ, Bertram MG, Billman PD, Blake CK, Blake S, Bliard L, Bonisoli-Alquati A, Bonnet T, Bordes CNM, Bose APH, Botterill-James T, Boyd MA, Boyle SA, Bradfer-Lawrence T, Bradham J, Brand JA, Brengdahl MI, Bulla M, Bussière L, Camerlenghi E, Campbell SE, Campos LLF, Caravaggi A, Cardoso P, Carroll CJW, Catanach TA, Chen X, Chik HYJ, Choy ES, Christie AP, Chuang A, Chunco AJ, Clark BL, Contina A, Covernton GA, Cox MP, Cressman KA, Crotti M, Crouch CD, D'Amelio PB, de Sousa AA, Döbert TF, Dobler R, Dobson AJ, Doherty TS, Drobniak SM, Duffy AG, Duncan AB, Dunn RP, Dunning J, Dutta T, Eberhart-Hertel L, Elmore JA, Elsherif MM, English HM, Ensminger DC, Ernst UR, Ferguson SM, Fernandez-Juricic E, Ferreira-Arruda T, Fieberg J, Finch EA, Fiorenza EA, Fisher DN, Fontaine A, Forstmeier W, Fourcade Y, Frank GS, Freund CA, Fuentes-Lillo E, Gandy SL, Gannon DG, García-Cervigón AI, Garretson AC, Ge X, Geary WL, Géron C, Gilles M, Girndt A, Gliksman D, Goldspiel HB, Gomes DGE, Good MK, Goslee SC, Gosnell JS, Grames EM, Gratton P, Grebe NM, Greenler SM, Griffioen M, Griffith DM, Griffith FJ, Grossman JJ, Güncan A, Haesen S, Hagan JG, Hager HA, Harris JP, Harrison ND, Hasnain SS, Havird JC, Heaton AJ, Herrera-Chaustre ML, Howard TJ, Hsu BY, Iannarilli F, Iranzo EC, Iverson ENK, Jimoh SO, Johnson DH, Johnsson M, Jorna J, Jucker T, Jung M, Kačergytė I, Kaltz O, Ke A, Kelly CD, Keogan K, Keppeler FW, Killion AK, Kim D, Kochan DP, Korsten P, Kothari S, Kuppler J, Kusch JM, Lagisz M, Lalla KM, Larkin DJ, Larson CL, Lauck KS, Lauterbur ME, Law A, Léandri-Breton DJ, Lembrechts JJ, L'Herpiniere K, Lievens EJP, de Lima DO, Lindsay S, Luquet M, MacLeod R, Macphie KH, Magellan K, Mair MM, Malm LE, Mammola S, Mandeville CP, Manhart M, Manrique-Garzon LM, Mäntylä E, Marchand P, Marshall BM, Martin CA, Martin DA, Martin JM, Martinig AR, McCallum ES, McCauley M, McNew SM, Meiners SJ, Merkling T, Michelangeli M, Moiron M, Moreira B, Mortensen J, Mos B, Muraina TO, Murphy PW, Nelli L, Niemelä P, Nightingale J, Nilsonne G, Nolazco S, Nooten SS, Novotny JL, Olin AB, Organ CL, Ostevik KL, Palacio FX, Paquet M, Parker DJ, Pascall DJ, Pasquarella VJ, Paterson JH, Payo-Payo A, Pedersen KM, Perez G, Perry KI, Pottier P, Proulx MJ, Proulx R, Pruett JL, Ramananjato V, Randimbiarison FT, Razafindratsima OH, Rennison DJ, Riva F, Riyahi S, Roast MJ, Rocha FP, Roche DG, Román-Palacios C, Rosenberg MS, Ross J, Rowland FE, Rugemalila D, Russell AL, Ruuskanen S, Saccone P, Sadeh A, Salazar SM, Sales K, Salmón P, Sánchez-Tójar A, Santos LP, Santostefano F, Schilling HT, Schmidt M, Schmoll T, Schneider AC, Schrock AE, Schroeder J, Schtickzelle N, Schultz NL, Scott DA, Scroggie MP, Shapiro JT, Sharma N, Shearer CL, Simón D, Sitvarin MI, Skupien FL, Slinn HL, Smith GP, Smith JA, Sollmann R, Whitney KS, Still SM, Stuber EF, Sutton GF, Swallow B, Taff CC, Takola E, Tanentzap AJ, Tarjuelo R, Telford RJ, Thawley CJ, Thierry H, Thomson J, Tidau S, Tompkins EM, Tortorelli CM, Trlica A, Turnell BR, Urban L, Van de Vondel S, van der Wal JEM, Van Eeckhoven J, van Oordt F, Vanderwel KM, Vanderwel MC, Vanderwolf KJ, Vélez J, Vergara-Florez DC, Verrelli BC, Vieira MV, Villamil N, Vitali V, Vollering J, Walker J, Walker XJ, Walter JA, Waryszak P, Weaver RJ, Wedegärtner REM, Weller DL, Whelan S, White RL, Wolfson DW, Wood A, Yanco SW, Yen JDL, Youngflesh C, Zilio G, Zimmer C, Zimmerman GM, Zitomer RA

Open source

DOI
10.1186/s12915-024-02101-x
Published
2025 Feb 6
Container
BMC biology
Publisher
Not recorded
Open access
yes

Credibility signals

limited evidence Score 45/100 under policy 1.0.0. This is a metadata assessment, not a judgment of the paper's conclusions.

Show all credibility signals

Cite this work

BibTeX

@article{allodium:10.1186/s12915-024-02101-x,
  title = {Same data, different analysts: variation in effect sizes due to analytical decisions in ecology and evolutionary biology.},
  author = {Gould E and Fraser HS and Parker TH and Nakagawa S and Griffith SC and Vesk PA and Fidler F and Hamilton DG and Abbey-Lee RN and Abbott JK and Aguirre LA and Alcaraz C and Aloni I and Altschul D and Arekar K and Atkins JW and Atkinson J and Baker CM and Barrett M and Bell K and Bello SK and Beltrán I and Berauer BJ and Bertram MG and Billman PD and Blake CK and Blake S and Bliard L and Bonisoli-Alquati A and Bonnet T and Bordes CNM and Bose APH and Botterill-James T and Boyd MA and Boyle SA and Bradfer-Lawrence T and Bradham J and Brand JA and Brengdahl MI and Bulla M and Bussière L and Camerlenghi E and Campbell SE and Campos LLF and Caravaggi A and Cardoso P and Carroll CJW and Catanach TA and Chen X and Chik HYJ and Choy ES and Christie AP and Chuang A and Chunco AJ and Clark BL and Contina A and Covernton GA and Cox MP and Cressman KA and Crotti M and Crouch CD and D'Amelio PB and de Sousa AA and Döbert TF and Dobler R and Dobson AJ and Doherty TS and Drobniak SM and Duffy AG and Duncan AB and Dunn RP and Dunning J and Dutta T and Eberhart-Hertel L and Elmore JA and Elsherif MM and English HM and Ensminger DC and Ernst UR and Ferguson SM and Fernandez-Juricic E and Ferreira-Arruda T and Fieberg J and Finch EA and Fiorenza EA and Fisher DN and Fontaine A and Forstmeier W and Fourcade Y and Frank GS and Freund CA and Fuentes-Lillo E and Gandy SL and Gannon DG and García-Cervigón AI and Garretson AC and Ge X and Geary WL and Géron C and Gilles M and Girndt A and Gliksman D and Goldspiel HB and Gomes DGE and Good MK and Goslee SC and Gosnell JS and Grames EM and Gratton P and Grebe NM and Greenler SM and Griffioen M and Griffith DM and Griffith FJ and Grossman JJ and Güncan A and Haesen S and Hagan JG and Hager HA and Harris JP and Harrison ND and Hasnain SS and Havird JC and Heaton AJ and Herrera-Chaustre ML and Howard TJ and Hsu BY and Iannarilli F and Iranzo EC and Iverson ENK and Jimoh SO and Johnson DH and Johnsson M and Jorna J and Jucker T and Jung M and Kačergytė I and Kaltz O and Ke A and Kelly CD and Keogan K and Keppeler FW and Killion AK and Kim D and Kochan DP and Korsten P and Kothari S and Kuppler J and Kusch JM and Lagisz M and Lalla KM and Larkin DJ and Larson CL and Lauck KS and Lauterbur ME and Law A and Léandri-Breton DJ and Lembrechts JJ and L'Herpiniere K and Lievens EJP and de Lima DO and Lindsay S and Luquet M and MacLeod R and Macphie KH and Magellan K and Mair MM and Malm LE and Mammola S and Mandeville CP and Manhart M and Manrique-Garzon LM and Mäntylä E and Marchand P and Marshall BM and Martin CA and Martin DA and Martin JM and Martinig AR and McCallum ES and McCauley M and McNew SM and Meiners SJ and Merkling T and Michelangeli M and Moiron M and Moreira B and Mortensen J and Mos B and Muraina TO and Murphy PW and Nelli L and Niemelä P and Nightingale J and Nilsonne G and Nolazco S and Nooten SS and Novotny JL and Olin AB and Organ CL and Ostevik KL and Palacio FX and Paquet M and Parker DJ and Pascall DJ and Pasquarella VJ and Paterson JH and Payo-Payo A and Pedersen KM and Perez G and Perry KI and Pottier P and Proulx MJ and Proulx R and Pruett JL and Ramananjato V and Randimbiarison FT and Razafindratsima OH and Rennison DJ and Riva F and Riyahi S and Roast MJ and Rocha FP and Roche DG and Román-Palacios C and Rosenberg MS and Ross J and Rowland FE and Rugemalila D and Russell AL and Ruuskanen S and Saccone P and Sadeh A and Salazar SM and Sales K and Salmón P and Sánchez-Tójar A and Santos LP and Santostefano F and Schilling HT and Schmidt M and Schmoll T and Schneider AC and Schrock AE and Schroeder J and Schtickzelle N and Schultz NL and Scott DA and Scroggie MP and Shapiro JT and Sharma N and Shearer CL and Simón D and Sitvarin MI and Skupien FL and Slinn HL and Smith GP and Smith JA and Sollmann R and Whitney KS and Still SM and Stuber EF and Sutton GF and Swallow B and Taff CC and Takola E and Tanentzap AJ and Tarjuelo R and Telford RJ and Thawley CJ and Thierry H and Thomson J and Tidau S and Tompkins EM and Tortorelli CM and Trlica A and Turnell BR and Urban L and Van de Vondel S and van der Wal JEM and Van Eeckhoven J and van Oordt F and Vanderwel KM and Vanderwel MC and Vanderwolf KJ and Vélez J and Vergara-Florez DC and Verrelli BC and Vieira MV and Villamil N and Vitali V and Vollering J and Walker J and Walker XJ and Walter JA and Waryszak P and Weaver RJ and Wedegärtner REM and Weller DL and Whelan S and White RL and Wolfson DW and Wood A and Yanco SW and Yen JDL and Youngflesh C and Zilio G and Zimmer C and Zimmerman GM and Zitomer RA},
  year = {2025},
  journal = {BMC biology},
  doi = {10.1186/s12915-024-02101-x},
  url = {https://doi.org/10.1186/s12915-024-02101-x}
}

RIS

TY  - JOUR
TI  - Same data, different analysts: variation in effect sizes due to analytical decisions in ecology and evolutionary biology.
AU  - Gould E
AU  - Fraser HS
AU  - Parker TH
AU  - Nakagawa S
AU  - Griffith SC
AU  - Vesk PA
AU  - Fidler F
AU  - Hamilton DG
AU  - Abbey-Lee RN
AU  - Abbott JK
AU  - Aguirre LA
AU  - Alcaraz C
AU  - Aloni I
AU  - Altschul D
AU  - Arekar K
AU  - Atkins JW
AU  - Atkinson J
AU  - Baker CM
AU  - Barrett M
AU  - Bell K
AU  - Bello SK
AU  - Beltrán I
AU  - Berauer BJ
AU  - Bertram MG
AU  - Billman PD
AU  - Blake CK
AU  - Blake S
AU  - Bliard L
AU  - Bonisoli-Alquati A
AU  - Bonnet T
AU  - Bordes CNM
AU  - Bose APH
AU  - Botterill-James T
AU  - Boyd MA
AU  - Boyle SA
AU  - Bradfer-Lawrence T
AU  - Bradham J
AU  - Brand JA
AU  - Brengdahl MI
AU  - Bulla M
AU  - Bussière L
AU  - Camerlenghi E
AU  - Campbell SE
AU  - Campos LLF
AU  - Caravaggi A
AU  - Cardoso P
AU  - Carroll CJW
AU  - Catanach TA
AU  - Chen X
AU  - Chik HYJ
AU  - Choy ES
AU  - Christie AP
AU  - Chuang A
AU  - Chunco AJ
AU  - Clark BL
AU  - Contina A
AU  - Covernton GA
AU  - Cox MP
AU  - Cressman KA
AU  - Crotti M
AU  - Crouch CD
AU  - D'Amelio PB
AU  - de Sousa AA
AU  - Döbert TF
AU  - Dobler R
AU  - Dobson AJ
AU  - Doherty TS
AU  - Drobniak SM
AU  - Duffy AG
AU  - Duncan AB
AU  - Dunn RP
AU  - Dunning J
AU  - Dutta T
AU  - Eberhart-Hertel L
AU  - Elmore JA
AU  - Elsherif MM
AU  - English HM
AU  - Ensminger DC
AU  - Ernst UR
AU  - Ferguson SM
AU  - Fernandez-Juricic E
AU  - Ferreira-Arruda T
AU  - Fieberg J
AU  - Finch EA
AU  - Fiorenza EA
AU  - Fisher DN
AU  - Fontaine A
AU  - Forstmeier W
AU  - Fourcade Y
AU  - Frank GS
AU  - Freund CA
AU  - Fuentes-Lillo E
AU  - Gandy SL
AU  - Gannon DG
AU  - García-Cervigón AI
AU  - Garretson AC
AU  - Ge X
AU  - Geary WL
AU  - Géron C
AU  - Gilles M
AU  - Girndt A
AU  - Gliksman D
AU  - Goldspiel HB
AU  - Gomes DGE
AU  - Good MK
AU  - Goslee SC
AU  - Gosnell JS
AU  - Grames EM
AU  - Gratton P
AU  - Grebe NM
AU  - Greenler SM
AU  - Griffioen M
AU  - Griffith DM
AU  - Griffith FJ
AU  - Grossman JJ
AU  - Güncan A
AU  - Haesen S
AU  - Hagan JG
AU  - Hager HA
AU  - Harris JP
AU  - Harrison ND
AU  - Hasnain SS
AU  - Havird JC
AU  - Heaton AJ
AU  - Herrera-Chaustre ML
AU  - Howard TJ
AU  - Hsu BY
AU  - Iannarilli F
AU  - Iranzo EC
AU  - Iverson ENK
AU  - Jimoh SO
AU  - Johnson DH
AU  - Johnsson M
AU  - Jorna J
AU  - Jucker T
AU  - Jung M
AU  - Kačergytė I
AU  - Kaltz O
AU  - Ke A
AU  - Kelly CD
AU  - Keogan K
AU  - Keppeler FW
AU  - Killion AK
AU  - Kim D
AU  - Kochan DP
AU  - Korsten P
AU  - Kothari S
AU  - Kuppler J
AU  - Kusch JM
AU  - Lagisz M
AU  - Lalla KM
AU  - Larkin DJ
AU  - Larson CL
AU  - Lauck KS
AU  - Lauterbur ME
AU  - Law A
AU  - Léandri-Breton DJ
AU  - Lembrechts JJ
AU  - L'Herpiniere K
AU  - Lievens EJP
AU  - de Lima DO
AU  - Lindsay S
AU  - Luquet M
AU  - MacLeod R
AU  - Macphie KH
AU  - Magellan K
AU  - Mair MM
AU  - Malm LE
AU  - Mammola S
AU  - Mandeville CP
AU  - Manhart M
AU  - Manrique-Garzon LM
AU  - Mäntylä E
AU  - Marchand P
AU  - Marshall BM
AU  - Martin CA
AU  - Martin DA
AU  - Martin JM
AU  - Martinig AR
AU  - McCallum ES
AU  - McCauley M
AU  - McNew SM
AU  - Meiners SJ
AU  - Merkling T
AU  - Michelangeli M
AU  - Moiron M
AU  - Moreira B
AU  - Mortensen J
AU  - Mos B
AU  - Muraina TO
AU  - Murphy PW
AU  - Nelli L
AU  - Niemelä P
AU  - Nightingale J
AU  - Nilsonne G
AU  - Nolazco S
AU  - Nooten SS
AU  - Novotny JL
AU  - Olin AB
AU  - Organ CL
AU  - Ostevik KL
AU  - Palacio FX
AU  - Paquet M
AU  - Parker DJ
AU  - Pascall DJ
AU  - Pasquarella VJ
AU  - Paterson JH
AU  - Payo-Payo A
AU  - Pedersen KM
AU  - Perez G
AU  - Perry KI
AU  - Pottier P
AU  - Proulx MJ
AU  - Proulx R
AU  - Pruett JL
AU  - Ramananjato V
AU  - Randimbiarison FT
AU  - Razafindratsima OH
AU  - Rennison DJ
AU  - Riva F
AU  - Riyahi S
AU  - Roast MJ
AU  - Rocha FP
AU  - Roche DG
AU  - Román-Palacios C
AU  - Rosenberg MS
AU  - Ross J
AU  - Rowland FE
AU  - Rugemalila D
AU  - Russell AL
AU  - Ruuskanen S
AU  - Saccone P
AU  - Sadeh A
AU  - Salazar SM
AU  - Sales K
AU  - Salmón P
AU  - Sánchez-Tójar A
AU  - Santos LP
AU  - Santostefano F
AU  - Schilling HT
AU  - Schmidt M
AU  - Schmoll T
AU  - Schneider AC
AU  - Schrock AE
AU  - Schroeder J
AU  - Schtickzelle N
AU  - Schultz NL
AU  - Scott DA
AU  - Scroggie MP
AU  - Shapiro JT
AU  - Sharma N
AU  - Shearer CL
AU  - Simón D
AU  - Sitvarin MI
AU  - Skupien FL
AU  - Slinn HL
AU  - Smith GP
AU  - Smith JA
AU  - Sollmann R
AU  - Whitney KS
AU  - Still SM
AU  - Stuber EF
AU  - Sutton GF
AU  - Swallow B
AU  - Taff CC
AU  - Takola E
AU  - Tanentzap AJ
AU  - Tarjuelo R
AU  - Telford RJ
AU  - Thawley CJ
AU  - Thierry H
AU  - Thomson J
AU  - Tidau S
AU  - Tompkins EM
AU  - Tortorelli CM
AU  - Trlica A
AU  - Turnell BR
AU  - Urban L
AU  - Van de Vondel S
AU  - van der Wal JEM
AU  - Van Eeckhoven J
AU  - van Oordt F
AU  - Vanderwel KM
AU  - Vanderwel MC
AU  - Vanderwolf KJ
AU  - Vélez J
AU  - Vergara-Florez DC
AU  - Verrelli BC
AU  - Vieira MV
AU  - Villamil N
AU  - Vitali V
AU  - Vollering J
AU  - Walker J
AU  - Walker XJ
AU  - Walter JA
AU  - Waryszak P
AU  - Weaver RJ
AU  - Wedegärtner REM
AU  - Weller DL
AU  - Whelan S
AU  - White RL
AU  - Wolfson DW
AU  - Wood A
AU  - Yanco SW
AU  - Yen JDL
AU  - Youngflesh C
AU  - Zilio G
AU  - Zimmer C
AU  - Zimmerman GM
AU  - Zitomer RA
PY  - 2025
JO  - BMC biology
DO  - 10.1186/s12915-024-02101-x
UR  - https://doi.org/10.1186/s12915-024-02101-x
ER  -

APA

E, G., HS, F., TH, P., S, N., SC, G., PA, V., F, F., DG, H., RN, A., JK, A., LA, A., C, A., I, A., D, A., K, A., JW, A., J, A., CM, B., M, B., K, B., SK, B., I, B., BJ, B., MG, B., PD, B., CK, B., S, B., L, B., A, B., T, B., CNM, B., APH, B., T, B., MA, B., SA, B., T, B., J, B., JA, B., MI, B., M, B., L, B., E, C., SE, C., LLF, C., A, C., P, C., CJW, C., TA, C., X, C., HYJ, C., ES, C., AP, C., A, C., AJ, C., BL, C., A, C., GA, C., MP, C., KA, C., M, C., CD, C., PB, D., AA, D. S., TF, D., R, D., AJ, D., TS, D., SM, D., AG, D., AB, D., RP, D., J, D., T, D., L, E., JA, E., MM, E., HM, E., DC, E., UR, E., SM, F., E, F., T, F., J, F., EA, F., EA, F., DN, F., A, F., W, F., Y, F., GS, F., CA, F., E, F., SL, G., DG, G., AI, G., AC, G., X, G., WL, G., C, G., M, G., A, G., D, G., HB, G., DGE, G., MK, G., SC, G., JS, G., EM, G., P, G., NM, G., SM, G., M, G., DM, G., FJ, G., JJ, G., A, G., S, H., JG, H., HA, H., JP, H., ND, H., SS, H., JC, H., AJ, H., ML, H., TJ, H., BY, H., F, I., EC, I., ENK, I., SO, J., DH, J., M, J., J, J., T, J., M, J., I, K., O, K., A, K., CD, K., K, K., FW, K., AK, K., D, K., DP, K., P, K., S, K., J, K., JM, K., M, L., KM, L., DJ, L., CL, L., KS, L., ME, L., A, L., DJ, L., JJ, L., K, L., EJP, L., DO, D. L., S, L., M, L., R, M., KH, M., K, M., MM, M., LE, M., S, M., CP, M., M, M., LM, M., E, M., P, M., BM, M., CA, M., DA, M., JM, M., AR, M., ES, M., M, M., SM, M., SJ, M., T, M., M, M., M, M., B, M., J, M., B, M., TO, M., PW, M., L, N., P, N., J, N., G, N., S, N., SS, N., JL, N., AB, O., CL, O., KL, O., FX, P., M, P., DJ, P., DJ, P., VJ, P., JH, P., A, P., KM, P., G, P., KI, P., P, P., MJ, P., R, P., JL, P., V, R., FT, R., OH, R., DJ, R., F, R., S, R., MJ, R., FP, R., DG, R., C, R., MS, R., J, R., FE, R., D, R., AL, R., S, R., P, S., A, S., SM, S., K, S., P, S., A, S., LP, S., F, S., HT, S., M, S., T, S., AC, S., AE, S., J, S., N, S., NL, S., DA, S., MP, S., JT, S., N, S., CL, S., D, S., MI, S., FL, S., HL, S., GP, S., JA, S., R, S., KS, W., SM, S., EF, S., GF, S., B, S., CC, T., E, T., AJ, T., R, T., RJ, T., CJ, T., H, T., J, T., S, T., EM, T., CM, T., A, T., BR, T., L, U., S, V. D. V., JEM, V. D. W., J, V. E., F, V. O., KM, V., MC, V., KJ, V., J, V., DC, V., BC, V., MV, V., N, V., V, V., J, V., J, W., XJ, W., JA, W., P, W., RJ, W., REM, W., DL, W., S, W., RL, W., DW, W., A, W., SW, Y., JDL, Y., C, Y., G, Z., C, Z., GM, Z., & RA, Z. (2025). Same data, different analysts: variation in effect sizes due to analytical decisions in ecology and evolutionary biology.. BMC biology. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12915-024-02101-x

Source records